43 Comments

I agree that you’ll get the best results by cooking the dark and white meat separately, although I just cooked a whole bird in my smoker, took it out when the breast hit the right temperature, and it turned out to be very good!

Expand full comment

My turkey was a big strong animal and breaking his legs and back bone was a Herculean task . Might get the butcher to do it for me next time . 😩

Expand full comment

Confiting the legs is genius. In a fit of bravado a few years ago, I spatchcocked my Thanksgiving turkey. With a hatchet. It was like roasting a pterodactyl, and I ended up having to joint off the legs and finish cooking them separately ANYWAY. Learned my lesson.

Expand full comment

My father used to break down his turkey by constantly berating the poor bird and wondering aloud why it couldn't be as good as the neighbor's turkey and that it must not be trying hard enough.

I like your method better.

Expand full comment
Dec 19, 2023Liked by Wil Reidie

What do you do with bread sauce? Is it a gravy?

Expand full comment

Wonderful lessons so the holidays aren't stressful! Happy almost one year Substackaversary! And may you and your loved ones have joyous Christmas and New Year!

Expand full comment

this is wildly helpful.

Expand full comment

Enjoyed reading this very much, Wil. Can tell how much work went into it, so thank you! I’ve never heard of bread sauce before. Does it take the place if gravy? We’ll be doing a rotisserie beef roast on the grill this year but definitely filing away the turkey leg confit for the future.

Expand full comment
Dec 16, 2023Liked by Wil Reidie

Hands down, this is the most helpful explanation of how to cook Xmas dinner I’ve ever read. Almost sad we will be away and not cooking this year - but I am saving this for next year. Great stuff Will. 🙏

Expand full comment

Very inspirational. I usually spatchcock my turkeys and smoke them on the grill outside. I think now I’ll still smoke but break down the turkey so each piece is cooked perfectly

Expand full comment
Dec 15, 2023Liked by Wil Reidie

I don’t boil my sprouts I stir fry them with lardons and chestnuts 😡😡😡

Expand full comment
Dec 15, 2023Liked by Wil Reidie

I rarely make anything more complex than toast these days due to my work schedule, but i absolutely loved this post. So rational and sane and considerate and intelligent... exquisitely done, Will. Thank you so much.

Expand full comment

Wonderful, Wil! I just watched the video, excellent!

Expand full comment
Dec 15, 2023Liked by Wil Reidie

What is the crown of the turkey? I have never heard of that.

Expand full comment

How marvelous! A sane approach to the nightmare! Thank you for breaking it down--there may be less cooking drinking in this house!

Expand full comment

Merry Christmas, Wil! I still haven't decided what I'm going to make yet, but your good ideas are leaning me in a turkey-ward direction. Thanks for the tips!

Expand full comment