29 Comments
User's avatar
dl meckes's avatar

The best thing I learned on social media was how to slice through small fruit and berries by putting them between two plastic container lids. Otherwise, I want people to speak less, show more technique, and have a voice as soothing as Ina Garten. (Julia excepted.) Jacques Pepin is still a superior content provider. But then, I am old and easily annoyed.

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

Can I have your permission to steal "old and easily annoyed" to use for my substack bio??

Expand full comment
Woke Marxist Pope's avatar

This explains a lot about what happens when someone at work (all chronically on social media) tells me they found a great recipe and I (only occasionally on Substack) ask them to tell me it…they never actually know it.

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

Not surprised to read this, Marina.

Expand full comment
Sarah Stanback-Young's avatar

Thank you so much for the mention. I think you are doing a wonderful job as is, stay well clear of social for as long as you can ;)

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

You're welcome! And thanks for reading.

Expand full comment
Kit Spahr's avatar

I admit to watching one recipe content creator’s Instagram videos because her hands as she chops, scoops into a pan, stirs, and plates are like watching a dance. She also doesn’t shout or try to be funny. It’s kind of soothing.

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

Who are you talking about? I'm interested in finding people using these forms to create content that is great for them. Hope that comes across in the piece.

Expand full comment
Kit Spahr's avatar

Justine Doiron @justine_snacks is her instagram address. I think she has a way of presenting the recipe that doesn't feel rushed. She has a nice website that contains her actual recipes...so you don't feel like you have to watch for the measurement details. She interacts with her followers in a helpful way.

Expand full comment
Kavita Favelle's avatar

I just checked out her account and really like it. I think a big part of that is that right there in the caption is the link to the website with full recipe info. I don't have to go off to the bio only to find that the link is no longer to the relevant recipe because I've only come across the insta post a while later. I don't have to send an inane comment to get a link DMed to me. I can just copy and paste the link she provides straight into a browser. Thanks for the recommendation!

And Will, thanks too for the Sandwiches of history guy reco, I love it!

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

I just love that account of his. Thanks for reading Kavita!

Expand full comment
Tony Lupton's avatar

If only Instagram allowed you to click directly on a link in a caption.

Expand full comment
Kavita Favelle's avatar

Yes, such a pain!

Expand full comment
Kit Spahr's avatar

Oh yeah…I forgot…the sandwich guy….my son told me about him. Very fun to watch.

Expand full comment
Sabrina Cooper's avatar

I, too, like Justine’s work, in part because she does as Wil says: She infuses her videos with life-writing, with tales of her relationship to the food she’s cooking. The context she provides makes her videos actually tolerable—like a food experience itself.

Expand full comment
Iwaska's avatar

I also really like Justine, thank you for mentioning her. She is also active on Substack at https://justinesnacks.substack.com/

Expand full comment
Sabrina Cooper's avatar

Oh how I agree with this piece, Wil. I’ve grown quite inured to the repeated rip of sliced sourdough over a mundane pan of beans. And the dance they all do upon trying a bite of said beans. I’ve tried some of these bean “recipes,” when I had nothing else in mind to cook—none made my eyes roll back in my head.

There’s a reason I read Diana Henry’s “Roast Figs, Sugar Snow,” even though my lovely list of food intolerances keeps me from enjoying nearly any of her recipes: Her “life-writing” is so evocative, so engaging that I don’t care whether I can eat the dish. It’s a lived experience itself.

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

Thanks so much, Sabrina. And thanks for reading. Also, Diana Henry is such a good writer, I agree.

Expand full comment
dl meckes's avatar

I'm sure I did not originate that comment!

Expand full comment
Lana-Emerald Mary Astin's avatar

Bravo 👊

Expand full comment
Pat Willard's avatar

Praise the lord, Wil! Thank you--feel so less alone. I have given up/ turned away from almost all social media, some for reasons you noted, and increasingly because it does little to portray the life that happens around a table. Most of all, it just takes away too much time from writing. There just isn't enough time in the world to do both. Except for Sandwiches of History--I love that guy! And Vine....I so miss Vine and how vibrant it was.

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

You're very kind, Pat. Glad you enjoyed the piece and thanks for reading! I know I'm missing out by not using social to promote myself someway, but I just don't have the time. I really am impressed by writers who manage to do it all.

Expand full comment
Pat Willard's avatar

I just feel time slipping away everytime I check in to social media. Plus my brain-width tends to short circuit then explode with the attempt to do more. Or maybe that shows how limited my time/creativity is. It needs so much protecting to get anywhere.

Expand full comment
Caz Hart's avatar

Nigela Lawson has a lot to answer for.

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

Oh but Caz isn't Nigella at least subtle about it all, just a little cheeky? Some of these creators I'm talking about here are just so explicit to the point it's just weird to me, it feels like a different thing entirely.

Expand full comment
Caz Hart's avatar

Lawson didn't even pretend to be subtle.

The problem is the young 'uns, who think they understood what Lawson was doing, and believe they've put a personal and modernized spin on her schtick. They're sadly mistaken. 😂

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

Haha, I think we agree on that point. 😊

Expand full comment
Hanne Blank Boyd's avatar

Subtle as a muddy boot print.

Expand full comment
Wil Reidie's avatar

Starting to think my use of the word subtle was a poor choice here. 😂 Tho compared to young personalities online, I think even a muddy boot is subtle.

Expand full comment